Evaluating Arguments: Evidence Quality
English
GCSE
9 questions
~18 mins
1 views0 downloads
About This Worksheet
A worksheet designed to enhance students' ability to evaluate the quality of evidence within arguments through analysis and annotation tasks.
Worksheet Preview
Full preview • 9 questions
Evaluating Arguments: Evidence Quality
Subject: EnglishGrade: GCSE
Name:
Date:
TeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizzTeachWhizz
Untitled Worksheet
Grade GCSE
A
Evaluating Evidence in Argumentation
In recent years, the debate over climate change has intensified, often driven by conflicting evidence presented by various groups. A prominent example is a report published by the Green Earth Foundation, which claims that global temperatures have risen by 1.5°C over the past century. This report primarily relies on temperature records collected from a limited number of weather stations, some of which are situated in urban areas prone to the urban heat island effect. Critics argue that such data may overstate the true extent of global warming. Conversely, a study by the Climate Science Consortium analyses satellite data, which indicates a more gradual temperature increase, suggesting that local anomalies can distort the overall picture. The discrepancy raises questions about the reliability of different evidence sources and highlights the importance of scrutinising data quality before accepting claims as fact.
1.
What is the main argument presented by the Green Earth Foundation report?
[2 marks]2.
Identify one potential flaw in the temperature data used by the Green Earth Foundation.
[2 marks]3.
Compare the evidence provided by the Green Earth Foundation with that of the Climate Science Consortium.
[3 marks]4.
Why might satellite data be considered more reliable in this context?
[2 marks]5.
Identify and explain one technique the author uses to present contrasting evidence.
[2 marks]6.
What is the significance of the phrase 'raises questions about the reliability of different evidence sources'?
[2 marks]7.
Based on the passage, how would you evaluate the strength of the overall argument about climate change evidence?
[6 marks]8.
What steps should scientists take to ensure the evidence they present is credible?
[4 marks]9.
Explain the importance of evaluating evidence quality in forming scientific conclusions.
[4 marks]Unlock Full Worksheet & Answers
Get instant access to the complete worksheet, answer keys, and 1,899 others
Unlimited answer keys for all worksheets
Download clean, formatted PDFs
Customize and remix any worksheet
Cancel anytime • No commitment • Start today
Quick Actions
What is Remix?
Create a new worksheet based on this one. Change the grade level, topic, number of questions, or difficulty - then generate a fresh version.
- • Change grade level (Grade 6 → Grade 7)
- • Swap topics (Harry Potter → Macbeth)
- • Add more questions (10 → 15)
- • Adjust difficulty
Details
- Created
- 1/1/2026
- Updated
- 1/1/2026
- Type
- worksheet