Question 1: What is the significance of the phrase 'special gift' in the context of the novel?

Answer: It refers to the clones' purpose of organ donation, highlighting societal views of their value.

Question 2: Identify and explain one technique used by Ishiguro to create a detached tone in the scene.

Answer: The clinical, unemotional language contributes to a sense of detachment.

Question 3: Analyse how the setting of Hailsham reflects the ethical themes in the story.

Answer: Hailsham's secluded and controlled environment symbolises the societal attempts to isolate and manipulate clones, raising ethical questions about autonomy and exploitation.

Question 4: What moral dilemma is faced by the characters in this scene?

Answer: They struggle with accepting their fate and questioning the morality of their use for organ donation.

Question 5: Identify one literary device used in the phrase 'special gift' and discuss its effect.

Answer: The phrase is an example of irony, as it conceals the true purpose of the clones' existence.

Question 6: Discuss how the novel encourages the reader to question societal ethics regarding cloning.

Answer: By presenting the clones’ perspectives and the moral ambiguity surrounding their treatment, the novel prompts the reader to consider the ethics of cloning and what constitutes humanity.

Question 7: Choose one technique used by Ishiguro in this scene and explain how it enhances the ethical themes.

Answer: The use of sparse, clinical language emphasises the emotional detachment, highlighting the ethical coldness of society’s treatment of clones.

Question 8: Reflect on a personal opinion: Do you think society today should consider the ethical implications of cloning? Why or why not?

Answer: Students should consider current scientific advancements and ethical debates, articulating their view on societal responsibilities and moral boundaries.