Historian A: Dr. Emily Carter – Economic Perspective "Dr. Carter argues that Lascar sailors were primarily viewed as vital economic contributors within the British maritime economy. She suggests that their skills and low wages made them indispensable, which led to their exploitation but also allowed them to sustain Britain's trade networks. She emphasizes the economic necessity of Lascar sailors for the British Empire and highlights how economic interests often overshadowed social concerns regarding their treatment. Her interpretation portrays Lascar sailors as crucial yet undervalued economic assets."

Historian B: Professor James Lewis – Social Perspective "Professor Lewis contends that Lascar sailors faced significant social marginalization and discrimination. He emphasizes their status as colonial subjects, often subjected to poor living conditions, racial prejudice, and limited rights. Lewis argues that their social position was rooted in racial and cultural differences, which led to their exploitation and social exclusion aboard ships and in port communities. His view highlights the social struggles and inequality experienced by Lascar sailors, framing them as victims of colonial and racial injustices.**