Historian A: John Guy – Political Strategy Perspective

"Historian John Guy argues that Henry VII's success in securing the throne was primarily due to his careful political strategy. He highlights Henry's use of marriage alliances, such as his marriage to Elizabeth of York, which united rival factions and strengthened his claim. Guy also emphasizes Henry's skill in manipulating the nobility and his use of legal reforms to consolidate power, ensuring stability and legitimacy for his reign. According to Guy, Henry's political acumen was central to his ability to establish a secure and lasting throne."

Historian B: Linda Porter – Personal Charisma and Ruthlessness Perspective

"Historian Linda Porter contends that Henry VII's rise was due to his personal qualities, including his charisma, determination, and ruthless actions. Porter suggests that Henry's ability to inspire loyalty and his ruthless suppression of potential rivals, such as Lambert Simnel and Perkin Warbeck, were crucial. She argues that Henry's personal traits allowed him to quickly eliminate threats and secure his position, rather than relying solely on political alliances or legal reforms. Porter believes Henry's personal qualities were essential to his success in establishing a stable monarchy."

Note: The two historians offer contrasting views—one emphasizing political strategy, the other focusing on personal traits—highlighting different interpretations of Henry VII's methods of securing the throne.