Historian A: John Guy – Political Perspective "John Guy argues that Henry VIII's treatment of his wives was primarily driven by political motives. He suggests that Henry sought to strengthen his dynasty, consolidate power, and secure a male heir at all costs. According to Guy, Henry's actions—divorcing, executing, or annulling his wives—were strategic moves to ensure political stability and avoid threats to his authority. This perspective views Henry as a ruler whose personal desires were subordinate to his political ambitions, framing his treatment of the wives as a calculated political strategy."

Historian B: Linda Porter – Personal/Emotional Perspective "Linda Porter emphasizes the personal and emotional aspects of Henry VIII's relationships with his wives. She contends that Henry's actions were deeply influenced by his personal passions, insecurities, and need for love and validation. Porter argues that Henry's obsession with producing a male heir was intertwined with his desire for companionship and personal identity. Her view portrays Henry as a complex individual whose personal feelings significantly impacted his decisions, leading to a pattern of volatile and often tragic treatment of his wives."