Historian A: Dr. Emily Carter – Economic Perspective

"Dr. Carter argues that scribes were primarily valued for their role in supporting the economy of ancient Egypt. They meticulously recorded transactions, taxes, and trade, which helped maintain the stability and wealth of the state. According to her, scribes were crucial for the administration of resources and wealth, making them essential to Egypt’s economic prosperity. She emphasizes how hieroglyphics enabled complex record-keeping that underpinned economic growth and state control. Her view highlights the functional importance of scribes in economic management."

Historian B: Professor John Lee – Social Perspective

"Professor Lee contends that scribes held a significant social and political status in ancient Egypt. He suggests that their literacy and mastery of hieroglyphics elevated them above common people, granting them influence at court and in religious affairs. Lee emphasizes that scribes were often part of the elite, shaping cultural and religious practices through their writings. His perspective underlines the social prestige and political power associated with scribal roles, viewing them as key figures in maintaining social hierarchy and religious traditions.**