Historian A: Jane Doe – Economic Perspective "Jane Doe argues that immigration was a vital driver of America's urban growth. She emphasizes that immigrants supplied the labor needed for factories, construction, and infrastructure projects, which fueled economic expansion. Doe highlights how cities expanded rapidly due to the influx of workers seeking job opportunities, contributing to economic prosperity and technological progress. She also points out that immigration created a diverse workforce that helped develop new industries, making American cities centers of innovation and economic power. Overall, her view sees immigration as essential for America's economic development during urbanization."

Historian B: John Smith – Social Perspective "John Smith contends that immigration led to significant social challenges that hindered urban development. He emphasizes issues such as overcrowding, poor living conditions, and social tensions among different immigrant groups. Smith argues that these problems caused urban areas to become areas of poverty, crime, and social unrest, which impeded sustainable growth. He criticizes the view that immigration solely contributed positively, suggesting instead that it created divisions and hardships for many city residents. His perspective sees urbanization as a complex process with both benefits and serious social drawbacks caused by immigration."

Questions: