Historian A: E.P. Thompson – Social Perspective "E.P. Thompson argues that the Tolpuddle Martyrs were true heroes of the working class, fighting for their rights against unfair laws and oppressive authorities. He emphasizes the social injustice faced by rural workers and sees their trial as part of a broader struggle for social justice and workers' rights. Thompson highlights the importance of their sacrifice in inspiring future labour movements and views their punishment as a reflection of the oppressive social order of the time. His interpretation focuses on the Martyrs as victims of unjust social and legal systems."

Historian B: David Smith – Legal and Political Perspective "David Smith contends that the Tolpuddle Martyrs were primarily political agitators who aimed to threaten the established social order. He suggests their formation of a friendly society and their subsequent trial were driven by political motives to undermine government authority and suppress trade unions. Smith emphasizes the legality of their actions and views their punishment as necessary to maintain law and order. His interpretation portrays the Martyrs as troublemakers, rather than victims of injustice, emphasizing the importance of law in society."

Questions: