Historian A: John Smith – Political Perspective

"Historian John Smith argues that the Barons' main role was to force King John into signing the Magna Carta to limit his absolute power. He emphasizes the political struggle between the monarchy and the nobility, viewing the Magna Carta primarily as a document of aristocratic privilege. Smith believes the Barons used the Charter as a tool to protect their own interests and secure political influence, rather than for wider social or legal reforms. This perspective highlights the importance of aristocratic power in shaping medieval governance."

Historian B: Emily Turner – Social Perspective

"Historian Emily Turner contends that the Barons' role in the Magna Carta was more about societal stability and the protection of rights. She suggests that the Barons, motivated by broader social concerns, sought to limit the abuse of royal authority to prevent societal unrest. Turner emphasizes the significance of the Charter in establishing early legal rights, viewing the Barons as representatives of wider social groups who aimed to improve justice and protect common people from royal tyranny."

Questions: