Historian A: John Doe – Economic Perspective "John Doe argues that Prohibition was primarily driven by economic factors, such as the desire to reduce government expenses related to law enforcement and to curb the economic influence of alcohol industries. He emphasizes that Prohibition created black markets which benefitted organized crime, and that these economic incentives ultimately undermined the law’s effectiveness. His analysis suggests that economic motivations were the key reason behind the implementation and persistence of Prohibition, despite its social costs."

Historian B: Jane Smith – Social Perspective "Jane Smith contends that Prohibition was mainly a social movement rooted in moral and religious values. She highlights that many Americans believed alcohol was the cause of social problems like crime and family violence. Smith points to the rise of temperance groups and the cultural shift towards moral reform as evidence that Prohibition was driven by social and religious ideals, rather than economic interests. Her view underscores the social desire to improve public morality as the main reason for Prohibition."