Historian A: John Carter – Economic Perspective

"Historian John Carter argues that the Middle Colonies' growth was primarily driven by economic factors. He emphasizes the region's fertile land, access to waterways, and the development of trade and manufacturing as the key reasons for its prosperity. Carter highlights how these economic advantages attracted settlers and fostered urban growth, making the Middle Colonies the economic hub of the colonies. He suggests that economic motivations shaped the region's development more than social or political reasons."

Historian B: Lisa Morgan – Social Perspective

"Historian Lisa Morgan contends that the social fabric of the Middle Colonies was the most important factor in its development. She points to the diverse population, including Quakers, Germans, and Dutch communities, which created a tolerant and cooperative society. Morgan argues that social stability and community values encouraged settlement and growth, shaping the region's character. According to her, social cohesion and multiculturalism were more influential than economic factors in the development of the Middle Colonies.**